PILLAR 02 · MARKET PULSE Market Commentary EP 053

Fixed vs Variable Mortgage Rates for Rentals: June 2024 Analysis

A solo episode with Dalia Barsoum, Principal Broker, Streetwise Mortgages
Play: Fixed vs Variable Mortgage Rates for Rentals: June 2024 Analysis
LISTEN ON ▶ YouTube
5 min · June 19, 2024 · 321 views
WHAT YOU'LL LEARN
  1. Where Canadian bond market traders forecast interest rates are headed over the next one to three years.
  2. How the Bank of Canada's June 5th rate cut impacts the fixed vs variable decision for rental properties.
  3. Why a five-year variable rate mortgage could save over $10,000 compared to a five-year fixed on a $500,000 rental mortgage.
  4. The surprising finding that a three-year fixed followed by a variable is mathematically equivalent to a five-year variable today.
  5. Why a two-year fixed now plus renewing into a variable later costs approximately $6,000 more than going variable immediately.
  6. How to choose between payment certainty and flexibility when financing rental properties.
  7. Why variable rates are a clear sweep for primary residences in the current environment.
Show Notes
Timestamps 5
Questions Answered 5
With the Bank of Canada's June 5th overnight rate cut stirring activity in Canadian bond markets, the fixed versus variable mortgage debate is heating up—especially for investors facing upcoming renewals. In this episode, Dalia Barsoum breaks down what professional bond market traders are forecasting for interest rates over the next one to three years, including the probability of additional cuts and why their outlook is the best indicator available.



Using a $500,000 rental property mortgage as a benchmark, Dalia reveals surprising numbers that challenge conventional thinking. While a five-year variable rate currently offers over $10,000 in savings compared to a fixed rate, the real shock is how a three-year fixed term followed by a variable stacks up against a five-year variable today. Whether you prioritize payment certainty or need the flexibility to sell and refinance across your portfolio, this data-driven analysis delivers a clear June 2024 strategy for rental property investors—and a definitive answer for primary residence owners too.
Where are Canadian mortgage rates expected to go over the next year?

According to Canadian bond market forecasts discussed in the episode, rates are expected to be approximately 1% lower a year from now through four quarter-percentage-point cuts by the Bank of Canada. The lowest interest rates are forecasted to arrive between two to three years from now, approximately 2% below current levels.

How much can I save with a variable rate versus a fixed rate on a rental property mortgage?

On a $500,000 mortgage, a five-year variable rate at prime plus 0.05% offers over $10,000 in savings compared to a five-year fixed rate over the mortgage term. However, taking a two-year fixed now and then renewing into a variable for three years is approximately $6,000 worse than going variable immediately.

Is a three-year fixed mortgage a good option for rental properties right now?

Surprisingly, taking a three-year fixed term today and then switching to a variable rate is mathematically equivalent to taking a five-year variable rate right away. For investors who prefer payment certainty over squeezing out every last dollar of savings, a three-year fixed offers an attractive price difference right now.

Why might a five-year variable rate make more sense for real estate investors?

A five-year variable rate offers flexibility should you need to sell the property or want to refinance during the mortgage term, which will likely become a viable option within the next one to two years. This flexibility is particularly valuable for real estate investors managing portfolio changes.

What is the recommendation for primary residences?

For primary residences, the analysis shows a clean and clear sweep favoring variable rates over fixed rates in the current June 2024 environment. The numbers strongly support going variable for owner-occupied properties.

Where do you start?